corporate governance

remuneration committee

The remuneration committee operates in accordance with its terms of reference, which is reviewed on an annual basis.

The main responsibilities include:

  • assisting the directors in fulfilling their responsibilities in establishing formal and transparent policies for people development and executive remuneration;
  • determining specific remuneration packages for senior executives of the company, including but not limited to basic salary, performance based incentives, share incentives, severance packages, pensions and other benefits.

Membership comprises four non-executive directors, all of whom are independent. The Chairman of the board, Buddy Hawton, chairs the committee. The Chief executive officer attends meetings by invitation in order to advise on remuneration of senior executives.

Senior executives do not participate in any discussions or decisions related to their own remuneration. The senior executives are defined as the executive directors of Woolworths Holdings Limited and the executive directors of Woolworths (Proprietary) Limited, a major subsidiary.

The remuneration committee made use of the services of external consultants to advise them on executive remuneration and to provide advice on market data, remuneration trends, retention strategy and performance related pay.

The Chairman of the remuneration committee attends the annual general meeting.

The committee met a total of four times during the year. The details of individual attendance at meetings are set out below.

remuneration strategy

Woolworths remuneration philosophy is designed to attract, develop and retain the passionate, committed and talented retailers who are required to effectively implement the overall Woolworths strategy and create value for our shareholders.

The remuneration strategy for senior executives is based on principles of performance and alignment with shareholders’ interests. A significant portion of senior executives’ total potential remuneration is performance related in order to drive the right behaviour to optimise company performance. Stretch targets are set annually in the context of future prospects of the group and the prevailing economic environment in which it operates.

senior executive remuneration

The senior executive total remuneration package consists of the following:

guaranteed total package including benefits

The guaranteed total package including benefits or cost to company of the senior executives is subject to annual review by the remuneration committee. The targeted pay position for guaranteed total package is aimed between the median and upper quartile when benchmarked against major South African retail and non-retail companies, and is adjusted according to individual responsibility and performance.

short-term incentive scheme

The short-term incentive scheme aims to focus the senior executives on the achievement of the short-term strategic, financial and operational components of the one-year plan. The incentive is payable on achieving certain pre-defined stretch targets, in line with our strategy, using an overall target to trigger the incentive pool and modifiers to determine payout. The scheme is designed to reward performance when targets are met, with higher rewards for exceptional performance.

In the current year, the overall target was set at a pre-defined level of profit before taxation and exceptional items (PBTAE). The modifiers used were headline earnings per share, return on equity, cost effective availability, market share, performance management and achievement of black economic empowerment targets.

During the current year the targeted PBTAE was achieved and the majority of the modifiers were attained.

A revised short-term incentive plan has been implemented for the 2007 financial year.

long-term incentives – share scheme

The share scheme is designed to align the behaviour of senior executives with the achievement of sustainable long-term financial goals and the interests of shareholders. Shares are considered an essential element of senior executive remuneration and comprise a material part of their remuneration. Grants are reviewed on an annual basis against our comparator group to ensure alignment with the market.

The number of shares that are granted each year depends on company performance against the pre-defined stretch targets. Grants are allocated at varying multiples of annual guaranteed total package. Grants are not awarded if minimum targets are not met.

The share scheme includes the following performance criteria and respective weightings:

Performance criteria Weighting
Total Shareholder Return (TSR) 25%
Financial measures
(HEPS growth and ROE%)
50%
Value added measures 25%

The criteria and weightings are reviewed on an annual basis.

TSR is measured relative to the performance of a comparator group of other retailers against a combination of the General Retailers Index and the Food and Drug Retailers Index. Targets set for growth in headline earnings per share and return on equity are also externally benchmarked against the above comparator group. On an annual basis the remuneration committee reviews the appropriateness of the comparator group.

The share purchase scheme table below shows the share allocation awarded for performance achieved in the 2006 financial year. The Chief executive officer received a grant of shares equal to 140% of his annual guaranteed total package, while the other senior executives received a grant of shares equal to 100% their annual guaranteed total package.

A general meeting will be convened on 15 November 2006 immediately following the annual general meeting in order to table amendments to the Woolworths Holdings Share Trust for shareholder approval. The effect of the amendments will be to revise the terms of the executive share scheme.

Details relating to the share trust are set out in the directors’ report.

The non-executive directors do not participate in short or long-term incentive schemes.

executive directors’ service contracts

The executive directors have employment contracts which do not contain notice periods exceeding twelve months and do not provide for pre-determined termination compensation in excess of one years’ salary and benefits.

directors’ fees and emoluments

Fees for non-executive directors are recommended by the remuneration committee to the board prior to approval by our shareholders at the annual general meeting.

The 2006 fees for non-executive directors were approved at the 2005 annual general meeting. The proposed fees for 2007, which will be tabled for approval at the forthcoming annual general meeting, are set out below together with the fees approved for 2006;

  Proposed Approved
  2007 2006
Services as directors
Fees:
Chairman of the board
Director (SA)
Director (UK)
 
R500 000
R102 000
£30 000
 
R450 000
R95 000
£29 400
Audit Committee
Chairman
Member
 
R112 000
R62 500
 
R100 000
R60 000
Risk Committee
Chairman
Member
 
R79 000
R39 500
 
R74 000
R37 000
Remuneration Committee
Chairman
Member
 
R90 000
R45 000
 
R84 000
R42 000
Transformation Committee
Chairman
Member
 
R79 000
R39 500
 
R74 000
R37 000
Nominations Committee
Member
 
R10 500
 
R10 000
* Sustainability Committee
Chairman
Member
 
R13 000
R6 500
 
-
-

* Established as a formal committee on 22 August 2006.

Emoluments paid to directors of Woolworths Holdings Limited in connection with the affairs of the company and its subsidiaries during the year ended 2006 and comparatives for 2005 are set out below:

      2006
          Retirement,     Interest  
          medical Per-   free loan  
          and related formance Other benefit Total
Name   Notes Fees Remuneration benefits bonus benefits (1) (2) remuneration
      R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s
Executive directors
                 
Simon Susman   3 145 2 995 605 3 426 22 1 013 8 206
Richard Inskip   4 - 1 866 199 1 410 102 781 4 358
Norman Thomson   3 145 1 543 187 1 181 31 799 3 886
      290 6 404 991 6 017 155 2 593 16 450
                   
        Remu-   Nomi- Trans-   Total non-
      Audit neration Risk nation formation   executive
      committee committee committee committee committee Other directors’
Name Notes Fees member member member member member fees fees
    R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s
Non-executive directors
                 
Buddy Hawton   450 - 84 - 10 37 12 593
Mair Barnes 5 338 - 42 - 10 - - 390
Nigel Colne 5 338 60 42 37 10 - 1 488
Brian Frost 6 95 - 42 37 10 9 26 219
Mike Leeming   95 100 - 74 - - 9 278
Chris Nissen 7 95 - - - - 74 8 177
Sindi Zilwa   95 60 - - - 37 11 203
Nolitha Fakude (past director) 8 40 - - - - 15 - 55
    1 546 220 210 148 40 172 67 2 403
Notes:                  
Other benefits includes discounts received on purchases made in our stores.
2 The interest free loan relates to the purchase of shares under the Woolworths Holdings Share Trust.The benefit for 2006 was calculated at 8% on the value of the outstanding loan.
3 Includes fees of A$30 000 payable by Country Road.
4 Other benefits include consultancy fees paid by Country Road.
5 Fees are paid in Sterling to British residents.
6 Includes payment of R18 000 in respect of the sustainability forum and Woolworths Trust.
7 Includes payment of R3 000 in respect of the sustainability forum.
8 Resigned on 25 November 2006.
    2005
                 
        Retirement,     Interest  
        medical and Performance Other free loan Total
Name Notes Fees Remuneration related benefits bonus benefits (1) benefit (2) remuneration
    R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s
Executive directors                
Simon Susman 3 139 2 767 567 0 18 562 4 053
Richard Inskip 4 - 1 695 180 0 98 503 2 476
Norman Thomson 3 139 1 433 183 0 28 432 2 215
    278 5 895 930 0 144 1 497 8 744
                 
      Audit Remuneration Risk Transformation   Total non-
      committee committee committee committee Other executive
Name Notes Fees member member member member fees directors’ fees
    R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s R000’s
Non-executive directors                
Buddy Hawton   350 - 80 - 35 11 476
Mair Barnes 5 324 - 40 - - - 364
Nigel Colne 5 324 47 40 35 - 1 447
Nolitha Fakude (past director)   90 - - - 35 1 126
Brian Frost 6 90 - 40 35 - 18 183
Mike Leeming   90 73 - 70 - 7 240
Chris Nissen   90 - - - 70 5 165
Sindi Zilwa   90 40 - - 35 9 174
    1 448 160 200 140 175 52 2 175
Notes:                
Other benefits includes discounts received on purchases made in our stores.
2 The interest free loan relates to the purchase of shares under the Woolworths Holdings Share Trust. The benefit for 2005 was calculated at 8.5% on the value of the outstanding loan.
3 Includes fees of A$30 000 payable by Country Road.
4 Other benefits include consultancy fees paid by Country Road.
5 Fees are paid in Sterling to British residents.
6 Includes payment of R7 500 in respect of the sustainability forum and Woolworths Trust.

directors’ interests in shares

Details of directors’ interests in the shares of the company are disclosed in the directors’ report. Shares purchased and options granted to executive directors in terms of the Woolworths Holdings Share Trust, which are outstanding for the year ended June 2006 are set out below:  

share purchase scheme
    June 2006          
        Shares awarded during          
    Shares at   or in respect of current   Shares sold  Shares at
    30 June 2005   year performance   during the year  30 June 2006
  Offer           Sale Profit    
Name Date Number Price Number Price Number Price (R'000) Number Price
Simon Susman May 1999 600 000 3.22           600 000 3.22
  May 2000 255 958 2.70           255 958 2.70
  December 2000 1 154 900 2.77           1 154 900 2.77
  June 2001 6 597 610 3.03           6 597 610 3.03
  August 2002 879 397 3.98           879 397 3.98
  August 2003 780 039 5.16           780 039 5.16
  December 2004 440 755 10.59           440 755 10.59
  August 2005     412 697 11.31       412 697 11.31
  September 2006 3     378 947 13.30       378 947 13.30
Total   10 708 659   791 644       11 500 303  
                     
Richard Inskip December 1998 113 667 2.60           113 667 2.60
  December 2000 585 290 2.77           585 290 2.77
  March 2001 500 000 2.82           500 000 2.82
  June 20011 350 000 3.03           350 000 3.03
  August 2002 376 884 3.98           376 884 3.98
  August 2003 314 922 5.16           314 922 5.16
  December 2004 274 788 10.59           274 788 10.59
  August 2005     165 782 11.31       165 782 11.31
  September 2006 3     155 263 13.30       155 263 13.30
Total   2 515 551   321 045         2 836 596  
                     
Norman Thomson2 December 1998 46 667 2.60           46 667 2.60
  May 1999 166 667 3.22           166 667 3.22
  December 2000 236 800 2.77           236 800 2.77
  March 2001 607 086 2.82           607 086 2.82
  June 20011 1 120 297 3.03           1 120 297 3.03
  August 2002 329 774 3.98           329 774 3.98
  August 2003 290 698 5.16           290 698 5.16
  December 2004 152 597 10.59           152 597 10.59
  August 2005     142 882 11.31       142 882 11.31
  September 2006 3     130 075 13.30       130 075 13.30
Total   2 950 586   272 957         3 223 543  
                     
Total   16 174 796   1 385 646         17 560 442  
                     
Notes:
All offers vest over a 5 year period at 20% per annum except the 14 May 1999 offer which vests over 7 years.
The vesting over the 7 year period is as follows: 20% vests after year 2, 10% vests after year 3, 4 and 5 respectively and 25% vests in years 6 and 7, respectively.
The shares granted in August 2006 relate to grants for the achievement of performance criteria for the year ended 30 June 2006.
1 The 1 June 2001 offer of shares were converted from deferred delivery to normal shares in this year.
2 In addition to the shares held through the share purchase scheme, Norman Thomson holds 2 620 shares in his own name. These shares are included in the shares disclosed in the directors’ report.
3 These shares were issued in respect of performance for the year ended 30 June 2006. These shares are not included in the directors’ interests in shares in the directors’ report as they were issued after 22 August 2006.
The loans used to purchase the shares must be repaid within ten years of the offer date.
Gains on sale of shares in previous year
         
  Offer       Sale Profit
Name Date Number Price Number Price (R’000)
Simon Susman December 1998 70 000 2.60 70 000 10.46 550
  May 2000 647 468 2.70 647 468 10.46 5 024
            5 574
Richard Inskip December 1998 63 667 2.60 63 667 10.46 500
  December 2000 81 609 2.77 81 609 10.46 628
            1 128
Norman Thomson December 1998 70 000 2.60 70 000 10.46 550
  December 2000 59 200 2.77 59 200 10.46 455
  March 2001 59 580 2.82 59 580 10.50 458
            1 463

As at 30 June 2006, the following proceeds and profit would have been earned on the disposal of the shares allocated, but not yet vested. This profit would have been forgone if the directors had resigned, and as such forms part of our retention strategy.

  Proceeds Profit
  on disposal on disposal
  (R’000) (R’000)
Simon Susman 21 716 9 499
Richard Inskip 9 937 4 159
Norman Thomson 7 827 3 493

Share option scheme 
    June 2006          
  Share options at Share options granted Share options exercised/ Share options
    30 June 2005 during the year transferred during the year at 30 June 2006 
Offer           Exercise Profit    
Name Date Number Price Number Price Number price (R000’s) Number Price
Richard Inskip May 1999 300 000 3.22     29 624 15.61 367 270 376 3.22
  June 2001 270 376 3.03     270 376 15.61 3 401 - -
Total   570 376       300 000   3 768 270 376  
Notes:
1.  There is no IFRS expense recognisable in respect of these options, as all options were offered prior to October 2001.
The 14 May 1999 offer vested over a 7 year period as follows: 20% vested after year 2, 10% vested after year 3, 4 and 5 respectively and 25% vested in years 6 and 7 respectively.
The June 2001 offer vested over a 5 year period at 20% per annum. 
The options must be exercised within 10 years of the offer date.

attendance at the remuneration committee meetings


 Aug Nov Feb May
Director 2005 2005 2006 2006
Buddy Hawton C N
Mair Barnes N
Nigel Colne N
Brian Frost N

C=Chairman
N=independent non-executive director